Skip to main content
ZCF

Home of cricket conversation, community and memory

Discussion

Who should be on that flight to Sri Lanka?

Zimbabwe Cricket Forum 44 posts 228 views

Discussion

ZCF Original

Opening post

The last time Zimbabwe toured Sri Lanka, they clinched the ODI series 3-2 and almost won a test match in Sri Lanka if it was not for Gunaratne and co. And there was no Brendan Taylor but Solomon Mire and Cremer played a vital part. The current Sri Lanka team is way more beatable than the one Zimbabwe won an ODI series over so the big question is who should be on that flight to Sri Lanka?

Muzarabani, Raza, Sean Williams, Craig Ervine, Burl, Chakabva, Madhevere, Shumba, Ngarava and Wellington are almost certain to be on that flight regardless of their current form.
Wangdue
ZCF Original
And Kaitano seems to have the temperament to be successful in ODIs, he was in good nick in Pro50s, scoring runs at a reasonable strike rate so I would love to see his name too on this tour. PJ is not that bad, he is a valuable asset with Taylor being gone permanently and I think ZC should give him the assurance that he is in their plans. Remember he was part of that successful tour to Sri Lanka so why not bring him?
Wangdue
ZCF Hall of Famer
we lack spin uleh.

Cremer was a huge thing that series.

Unless Burl takes his spinners to the next level we are in trouble.

But you know what? It is possible.
ZCF Hall of Famer
I'd like to see Evans get the nod. He's going to be a decent all-rounder.
ZCF Original
I think spin will not play as big part in ODI as it plays in test matches in the subcontinent but it is for sure that the Lankans will do everything to beat Zimbabwe since there is much more at stake this time. Hopefully Williams and Raza, the best players of spin in Zimbabwe team in my opinion, will come good this time around with other batters chiping in with reasonable contributions.
Wangdue
ZCF Original

Googly wrote: ↑Wed Dec 29, 2021 8:32 am

I'd like to see Evans get the nod. He's going to be a decent all-rounder.


I had a one to one conversation with Brad Evans, asked him if he has the ambition to play for Zimbabwe and his answer was " I absolutely has the ambition to play for Zimbabwe but I am injured at the present"
Wangdue
ZCF Hall of Famer
He had an ankle operation, a complex repair of a torn ligament. I'd think he's probably 90% fit by now. He'd probably struggle in a test but would be OK for 10 overs shortly. He's been a bit unlucky with stop start covid and this injury in the first game. Watch when he bowls in tandem with another good bowler, he takes wickets, and he has enormous talent with the bat, way more than our other seaming all rounders. He just needs to figure out how not to play get out shots at inopportune times. That's the Zim curse, but I think he can figure his game out and become a really good player.
Veteran
My list of 20 players, accomodating Covid-19 and injury-unforced absence

Williams (c)

Ervine

Raza

Chakabva (wk)

Burl

Kaitano

Marumani

Shumba

Madhevere

Campbell J

Madande (wk)

Masakadza W

Mavuta

Masuku

Muzarabani

Ngarava

Chavhanga

Mumba

Nyauchi

Chatara

Based on pro50 stats and having reasonable performances in past ODIs
Legend
As per Sri Lanka is concerned they will have the services of world class Hasaranga, Dhananjaya, Chameera, Kumara from that 2017 series against Zim.

Hasaranga has become world class now, and new sensation Asalanka, Rajapaksha, Shanaka, Karunaratne have taken out Sri Lanka from their down phase. Micky Arthur has done great work and things were improving but he left.

It will be interesting if Sri Lanka bring back Kusal Mendis & Gunathilaka who has been in impressive form in recently held T20 League. Dickwella might get missed out as he failed after return from ban
ZCF Hall of Famer
He also had the benefit of being in a good cricketing environment growing up, went overseas, played decent club and county and is obviously committed to Zim as his passport prevents him from going elsewhere. He ticks a lot of boxes. He actually got shortchanged at school and batted down the order as a bowler when he should have batted at 5 or 6. He played in good junior teams that had good batting line ups and in my view was short changed in the batting dept, he should have been given way more opportunities and we wouldn't be having this conversation, he'd be set up as a dead cert and not having to find a way in.

Private school sides try and find room for everyone so sad parents don't stop donating. 😂

If you're a batsman then you don't do much bowling, and vice versa.
Veteran
Looking forward to the series but I’m really worried that they will just spin us out of the game. Can’t see our spinners being able to compete.

I assume it will be an 18 man squad so here is what I would say (if it is 15, then bottom 3 will miss out):

Sean Williams

Craig Ervine (c)

Ryan Burl

Regis Chakabva (wk)

Blessing Muzarabani

Richard Ngrava

Wellington Masakadza

Brandon Mavuta

Luke Jongwe

Wessly Madhevere

Sikander Raza

T kaitano

Milton Shumba

Clive Madande (wk)

Tendai Chatara

Ernest Masuku (if 18)

Donald Tiripano (if 18)

T Mutombodzi (if 18)

I think some of those selections would be fair based on season form, I’m a little biased towards Madande but hoping he is taken into consideration as the backup keeper, if not that will probably be mutumbami :cry:

Masuku has had a great season, same for Mutombodzi and kaitano, that’s why I have included them.

I’m sure I have probably forgot someone so apologies in advance.

My XI for game 1. Assuming spin friendly conditions:

Kaitano

Chakabva (wk)

Madhevere

Ervine

Williams

Shumba

Raza

Mavuta

Masakadza

Ngrava

Muzarabani

That gives us 8 bowling options, only 2 pacers is risky but I don’t think the conditions will suit them, bat down to 9 with this 11 as well.

Looking forward to the series.

Cal
ZCF Hall of Famer
I keep punting this guy.

If I had to choose between Marumani, Campbell and Evans I'd choose Evans. Marumani will get the nod by default, but he's got some work to do. Great eye, but as we said, everyone should have one at international level. Evans has already got the technique and the eye but has not been given an extended opportunity with the bat.

I think he has the ability to be a better bat than Shumba, it's all about someone giving him opportunity and him taking it with both paws. Good players often just disappear because they don't have a backer.
ZCF Hall of Famer
My squad:

Takudzwa Kaitano

Kevin Kasuza

Craig Ervine

Sean Williams

Sikandar Raza

Regis Chakabva

Milton Shumba

Wessly Madhevere

Ryan Burl OR Jonathan Campbell

Luke Jongwe

Wellington Masakadza

Brandon Mavuta OR Ainsley Ndlovu

Big Rich Ngarava

Blessing Muzarabani

Larry Chatara OR Carl Mumba

That gives a 15-man squad. 18 if we take both Burl+Jono and Larry+Mumba and Mavuta+Ndlovu.

Burl is out of form. Needs a kick up the arse and Campbell has had a good season. Big call to make.

Chatara has been poor in national colours recently. Maybe Mumba deserves a chance gain.

- Masuku? Great season but I don't rate him. Wouldn't pick.

- Evans? Hasn't played for a couple of months, they won't pick him. Bad timing.

- Madande? Too soon.

- Mutombodzi? No thanks. Backwards step.

- Tiripano? Please please please please never pick him again.

- PJ Moor? Hasn't quite done enough for a recall yet imo.
Veteran

lobsang wrote: ↑Wed Dec 29, 2021 8:36 am


Googly wrote: ↑Wed Dec 29, 2021 8:32 am

I'd like to see Evans get the nod. He's going to be a decent all-rounder.


I had a one to one conversation with Brad Evans, asked him if he has the ambition to play for Zimbabwe and his answer was " I absolutely has the ambition to play for Zimbabwe but I am injured at the present"


Ive just looked up Brad Evans stats/profile, he is only 25 y.o, has FC century, bowls right arm fast, 1X5for, 3X4for....isnt this the allrounder we've been looking for since Chigumbura retired?? why are we nickel-and-diming on bits-and-pieces "allrounders" like Jongwe, when we have a bloke of the same age, with better stats, international club cricket experience ?? He should be in the team like yesterday, what are we doing?? Or perhaps reports we are getting from insiders aren't true and like Murray, Schadendorf, Myers and others, Evans doesn't want anything to do with ZimCricket at an international level?
ZCF Hall of Famer
Good calls.

I think Mavuta has plateaued. Showed lots of early promise and never really followed through.

Campbell tends to revert to darting it in when he's under pressure. Hard to trust your flight and length and keep at it when they're being positive against your bowling. He needs to work on that. He's got ability though. As you said big call choosing Campbell over Burl, I wouldn't be doing that until Campbell had had a couple of really good domestic seasons.
ZCF Hall of Famer
I've always enjoyed Jongwe's chutzpah, and there's no doubting he's a good player. He used to be a much better batsman than he is now, he's let that slip, but Evans is better than him and has that all-important capacity to improve even more.
Veteran

secretzimbo wrote: ↑Wed Dec 29, 2021 9:22 am

My squad:

Takudzwa Kaitano

Kevin Kasuza

Craig Ervine

Sean Williams

Sikandar Raza

Regis Chakabva

Milton Shumba

Wessly Madhevere

Ryan Burl OR Jonathan Campbell

Luke Jongwe

Wellington Masakadza

Brandon Mavuta OR Ainsley Ndlovu

Big Rich Ngarava

Blessing Muzarabani

Larry Chatara OR Carl Mumba

That gives a 15-man squad. 18 if we take both Burl+Jono and Larry+Mumba and Mavuta+Ndlovu.

Burl is out of form. Needs a kick up the arse and Campbell has had a good season. Big call to make.

Chatara has been poor in national colours recently. Maybe Mumba deserves a chance gain.

- Masuku? Great season but I don't rate him. Wouldn't pick.

- Evans? Hasn't played for a couple of months, they won't pick him. Bad timing.

- Madande? Too soon.

- Mutombodzi? No thanks. Backwards step.

- Tiripano? Please please please please never pick him again.

- PJ Moor? Hasn't quite done enough for a recall yet imo.


Good team, I would alter the opening partnership, kaitano and Kasuza are both test-style batsmen, I doubt they will cash in on the bowling power-play, which will create unnecessary pressure for the middle order and tail to set a defendable score or chase, I would choose one of these two (my preference is Kaitano) to be partnered by Chakabva. Luke Jongwe has he brash arrogance and confidence with the ball, which is okay, but If we are strictly picking an allrounder, as in an okay bowler who can bat, then Tiripano is ahead of Jongwe by a long shot
ZCF OriginalLegend
With the way things go I wouldn't be surprised to see K-Long and Marumani in there. Sometimes I think they pick players based on who has a national contract and who doesn't. So there is more chances of K-Long going than PJ for example who turned down a national contract
ZCF Hall of Famer
Sri Lanka seem to have found some really good players in Asalanka (I think he is the real big deal for SLN), Nissanka, Theekshana, Hasaranga.

I think Zimbabwe, as much as I'd LOVE to see them win, will struggle to win a game. I hope to be proved wrong.

Most likely team

Madhevere

Chakabva

Ervine

Williams

Shumba

Raza

Burl

Jongwe

Wellington

Blessing

Ngarava

---------------------------------

Mumba

Tiripano

J Campbell

Kaitano

I think this will be the squad. I'd love to see Moor in there but I'm not sure if he will get the nod. Myers not there unfortunately. May be the squad will carry a few more players considering the threat of covid. So some youngsters may get in there.
ZCF Hall of Famer

Tinah09 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 29, 2021 10:04 am

Good team, I would alter the opening partnership, kaitano and Kasuza are both test-style batsmen, I doubt they will cash in on the bowling power-play, which will create unnecessary pressure for the middle order and tail to set a defendable score or chase, I would choose one of these two (my preference is Kaitano) to be partnered by Chakabva. Luke Jongwe has he brash arrogance and confidence with the ball, which is okay, but If we are strictly picking an allrounder, as in an okay bowler who can bat, then Tiripano is ahead of Jongwe by a long shot


I think Kaitano and Kasuza have done well enough in limited overs this season and last season to deserve a chance in this format. We don't really have any other options at the top - unless Ervine and/or Reggie open, which is less than ideal for both. Idk why PJ is wasting his time batting at 3 in domestics. He should be opening if he wants to get in this team.

And I know I've beaten this drum to death, but Tiripano is woeful. He is an absolutely awful bowler at international level. People need to look at the last year or so, not five years ago. I honestly think there are club cricketers in Zim who are better bowlers nowadays. He's past it. We can't be picking dreadful bowlers just because they can score 30 runs from number 9. Thats what losing teams do. Thats a losing attitude, an attitude of minnows. If anyone is taking Jongwe's place, then its probably going to be Evans - but obviously he's been injured. I like Jongwe a lot. Where as the best Tiripano can do is hold an end up for a while and hope not to do too much damage, Jongwe is a gamechanger. He might bowl 3 overs of dross but he'll pop up and take the key wicket in the game when the opposition are 80-0 or something. He makes stuff happen when heads are down, and I really like that. He's a livewire too, and a bit mad - a good person to have on tour. Jongwe is a much much better bowler than Don.

Reply

Login to reply.